Agency and Access: Power over Identity Language and Representations of Transness in Saskatchewan’s Use of Preferred Name and Pronouns by Students Policy
A research paper originally published in the Global Undergraduate Awards digital library (see link for full essay). This essay was ranked as highly commended in the category of Linguistics in 2024 (awarded to all entries in the top 10% of submissions in a given category), and selected as the regional winner in Linguistics for the Americas.
This paper analyzes the language used in the Government of Saskatchewan’s (2023) recent policy, Use of Preferred Name and Pronouns by Students, which the Saskatchewan government announced on August 22, 2023. Under this policy, students under the age of 16 must obtain parental consent in order to be addressed by a name or pronouns that differ from those assigned to them at birth, even in cases where disclosure to their parents can reasonably be expected to endanger the student. This legislation emerges from a context of gender policing and educational surveillance in North America and reflects assumptions of absolute parental authority over student identity. I use Carol Bacchi’s (2009) approach to policy analysis to examine how the language in this policy constructs the ‘problem’ of unauthorized trans identity as a threat to student safety. This language develops and communicates ideologies of parental rights, support and safety, and danger related to transgender identity. I consider how the presuppositions of the policy position parental consent as necessary and trans identity as a threat, particularly in relation to how the policy repeatedly claims student safety as its purpose. I then speculate as to the consequences this policy could have for students attending Saskatchewan schools. In particular, I examine how the policy structures power over identity-based language, the ways power limits student potential for self-determination, the policy’s erasure and isolation of trans identities, and the potential broader consequences of the policy as they relate to future policy-making and transphobic violence. Ultimately, I aim to interrogate how Saskatchewan’s policy problematizes trans students’ control over their identity, transfers this control away from students to their parents, and limits their agency and access to self-determination.
Keywords: policy analysis, education, identity-based language, trans self-determination, parental rights
References
Bacchi, C. L. (2009). Analysing policy: What’s the problem represented to be? Pearson Australia.
Fowler, M. M., & Mountz, S. (2023). Discipline, erasure, and silenced subjectivities: A critical discourse analysis of Florida’s 2022 parental rights in education act. Affilia. https://doi.org/10.1177/08861099231197164
Government of Saskatchewan. (2023). Use of Preferred First Name and Pronouns by Students. https://www.saskatchewan.ca/-/media/news-release-backgrounders/2023/aug/policy---use-of-preferred-first-name-and-pronouns-by-students.pdf
Herman, E. S., & Chomsky, N. (1988). Manufacturing consent: the political economy of the mass media. Pantheon Books.
Herriot, L., Burns, D. P., & Yeung, B. (2018). Contested spaces: Trans-inclusive school policies and parental sovereignty in Canada. Gender and Education, 30(6), 695–714. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540253.2017.1396291
Ingrey, J. (2018). Problematizing the cisgendering of school washroom space: Interrogating the politics of recognition of transgender and gender non-conforming youth. Gender and Education, 30(6), 774–789. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540253.2018.1483492
Malins, P. (2016). How inclusive is “inclusive education” in the Ontario elementary classroom?: Teachers talk about addressing diverse gender and sexual identities. Teaching and Teacher Education, 2016(54), 128–138. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2015.11.004
Mayo, C. (2021). Distractions and Defractions: Using parental rights to fight against the Educational Rights of transgender, nonbinary, and gender diverse students. Educational Policy, 35(2), 368–382. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904820983033
Zimman, L. (2019). Trans self-identification and the language of neoliberal selfhood: Agency, power, and the limits of monologic discourse. International Journal of the Sociology of Language, 2019(256), 147–175. https://doi.org/10.1515/ijsl-2018-2016